Boat style

Should you book a pirate ship or a catamaran cruise in Aruba? Both offer beautiful Caribbean views, sunset sailing and snorkeling adventures, but the onboard experiences can be surprisingly different.
A catamaran is our recommendation for travelers who want more choice, from relaxed sunset sails and snorkeling cruises to lunch excursions and private charters.
A pirate ship cruise is our recommendation for visitors who want a distinctive wooden sailing vessel, a playful atmosphere and the possibility of rope-swing fun on selected snorkeling trips.
The best choice depends on whether you're traveling as a couple, with children, with friends or primarily to snorkel.
This guide compares Aruba's pirate-ship and catamaran experiences, including prices, comfort, activities, popular operators and which cruises are worth considering.
ArubaBuddies is an independent Aruba travel guide. We may earn a commission from bookings made through our links, at no additional cost to you.
Jump to a section
| Feature | Catamaran | Pirate ship |
|---|---|---|
| Boat design | Twin-hull vessel | Pirate-themed wooden schooner |
| Atmosphere | Varies from relaxed to lively | Generally playful and social |
| Operators | Multiple choices | Jolly Pirates is the main operator featured here |
| Sunset cruises | Yes | Yes |
| Snorkeling cruises | Yes | Yes |
| Rope swings | Available on selected boats | Signature feature of selected Jolly Pirates trips |
| Water slides | Available on selected boats | Not a standard feature |
| Food | Varies: appetizers, lunch or dinner | Depends on the selected cruise |
| Open bar | Common on selected cruises | Available on selected cruises |
| Private charters | Several options | Check directly for group arrangements |
| Best for | Couples, families and travelers wanting choice | Adventurous groups and pirate-ship enthusiasts |
Choose a catamaran if you want the widest selection of tours, a relaxed sunset cruise, a snorkeling-and-lunch experience or a private boat.
Choose a pirate ship if the boat's character and social atmosphere are important parts of your vacation.
For couples seeking a romantic sunset, we'd generally start with a catamaran.
For adventurous families and groups of friends, we'd seriously consider Jolly Pirates.
However, the individual tour matters more than the boat category alone.
The cost depends on the operator, duration, inclusions and whether you're booking a shared or private experience. Here are examples from the ArubaBuddies tour listings.
| Experience | Boat | Previously listed from |
|---|---|---|
| Banana Adventure Tropical Sunset Sail | Catamaran | $50 |
| Arusun Catamaran Sunset Sail | Catamaran | $55 |
| Dolphin Catamaran Sunset Cruise | Catamaran | $59 |
| Jolly Pirates Sunset Sail with Open Bar | Pirate ship | $62 |
| Arusun Catamaran Snorkeling Sail | Catamaran | $63 |
| Dolphin Catamaran Snorkel and Sail | Catamaran | $69 |
| Jolly Pirates Afternoon Snorkeling Sail | Pirate ship | $78 |
| Red Sail Sunset Sail with Appetizers | Catamaran | $92 |
| Jolly Pirates Grub and Grog Dinner Sail | Pirate ship | $117 |
These are historical starting prices from ArubaBuddies' displayed listings, not live quotes. Prices, inclusions and availability can change.
Not necessarily.
Several catamaran sunset cruises have been listed at lower starting prices than Jolly Pirates' standard sunset sail.
However, premium catamaran experiences with dinner, additional amenities or private use can cost considerably more.
Compare the actual tours rather than assuming one boat type is always cheaper.

A catamaran has two hulls connected by a deck structure.
In Aruba, catamarans are commonly used for sunset cruises, snorkeling excursions, lunch sails and private charters.
The experience varies considerably by operator.
Some catamarans are designed for relaxed sailing and sunset views. Others offer music, open bars, snorkeling stops, water slides or rope swings.
More variety: Aruba has several catamaran operators, offering different prices, itineraries and onboard amenities.
Sunset options: You can choose a basic sunset sail, an appetizer cruise or a dinner experience.
Snorkeling excursions: Many catamarans visit popular snorkeling areas along Aruba's western coastline.
Private charters: Couples, families and groups can book selected vessels for exclusive use.
Different atmospheres: You can choose a relatively relaxed experience or a more activity-focused excursion.
Some travelers prefer the layout and motion characteristics of a twin-hull catamaran.
However, comfort depends on vessel design, passenger capacity, weather and sea conditions.
A catamaran isn't automatically smoother in every situation, and no boat guarantees that passengers won't experience seasickness.

Aruba's best-known pirate-themed sailing experience is Jolly Pirates.
Its wooden schooner creates a very different atmosphere from a modern catamaran.
Rather than simply providing transportation to snorkeling locations, the boat itself is a major part of the experience.
Distinctive setting: A wooden pirate-style sailing vessel makes the excursion memorable.
Social atmosphere: Jolly Pirates is particularly appealing to groups and travelers who enjoy a lively outing.
Snorkeling adventures: Selected cruises combine sailing with snorkeling stops.
Rope-swing fun: The operator is known for rope-swing activities on suitable excursions.
Sunset sailing: You can also book an evening pirate-ship cruise without making snorkeling the focus.
No. Don't assume that the rope swing operates on every departure.
The activity is particularly associated with Jolly Pirates snorkeling trips.
Whether it's offered on a specific cruise depends on the advertised itinerary, sea conditions and operator instructions. If the rope swing is your main reason for booking, confirm that it's included in your chosen experience.
If you're primarily interested in sunset views, catamarans offer several options at different price points.
Previously listed from $59 | Approximately 2 hours
A relatively affordable catamaran sunset experience for visitors who want the coastline and sunset without a premium dinner cruise. Best for: Budget-conscious couples and groups.

Delphi Watersports Aruba
A catamaran sunset sail. Previously listed from $59 for about 2 hours.
Check AvailabilityPreviously listed from $92 | Approximately 2 hours
Red Sail offers a more relaxed sunset experience with appetizers and drinks. It's one of our preferred options for couples looking for a romantic evening. Best for: Couples, anniversaries and relaxed sunset sailing.

Red Sail Sports - Aruba
Catamaran sunset sailing with appetizers and an open bar. Previously listed from $92 for about 2 hours.
Check AvailabilityPreviously listed from $50 | Approximately 2 hours
Another option worth comparing if price is an important factor. Check the current listing for departure location, drinks and other inclusions. Best for: Travelers comparing lower-priced sunset cruises.

Segway Aruba
A lower-priced catamaran sunset sail. Previously listed from $50 for about 2 hours.
Check AvailabilityFor a romantic evening, we'd lean toward Red Sail's appetizer sail.
For travelers prioritizing price, we'd compare Dolphin, Arusun and Banana Adventure.
The best value depends on the current fare, what is included and the atmosphere you're looking for. See Best Sunset Cruises in Aruba.
Catamarans are also popular for snorkeling trips. Many excursions combine sailing with stops at reefs, shipwrecks or other coastal locations.
Previously listed from $69 | Approximately 3 hours
A strong option for travelers who want snorkeling combined with a catamaran sailing experience. Best for: First-time visitors and groups seeking snorkeling and onboard activities.

Delphi Watersports Aruba
Catamaran snorkeling with an open bar. Previously listed from $69 for about 3 hours.
Check AvailabilityPreviously listed from $63 | Approximately 2.5 hours
A shorter snorkeling sail worth considering if you don't want to spend half the day on a boat. Best for: Travelers looking for a relatively short catamaran snorkeling experience.

Aruba Watersports Center
A shorter catamaran snorkeling sail. Previously listed from $63 for about 2.5 hours.
Check AvailabilityPreviously listed from $79.99 | Approximately 3 hours
This excursion combines snorkeling with a morning sailing experience and advertised brunch service. Best for: Couples and travelers who prefer a morning departure with food included.

Octopus Snorkeling, Sailing & Sunset Tours - Private Charter - Boat Rental Aruba
A morning catamaran sail with snorkeling, mimosas and brunch. Previously listed from $79.99 for about 3 hours.
Check AvailabilityA catamaran is an excellent choice if you want to compare different snorkeling itineraries, departure times and food packages.
But don't choose based on the boat type alone. Check the actual snorkeling locations, time in the water, equipment provided and swimming requirements.
Jolly Pirates offers several experiences, including sunset sailing, snorkeling and dinner options.
Previously listed from $78 | Approximately 3 hours
Our preferred pirate-ship option for an active daytime excursion. Check the current itinerary for rope-swing availability and snorkeling stops. Best for: Adventurous families, friends and active travelers.

Jolly Pirates Sailing Cruises & Snorkeling Aruba
Pirate-ship sailing with snorkeling. Previously listed from $78 for about 3 hours.
Check AvailabilityPreviously listed from $62 | Approximately 2 hours
The pirate-ship alternative to a conventional catamaran sunset cruise. Best for: Groups and couples who enjoy a lively atmosphere.

Jolly Pirates Sailing Cruises & Snorkeling Aruba
A pirate-style sunset sail with an open bar. Previously listed from $62 for about 2 hours.
Check AvailabilityPreviously listed from $117 | Approximately 2 hours
A dinner-oriented alternative to the standard sunset cruise. Best for: Groups and couples seeking a pirate-themed evening with a meal.

Jolly Pirates Sailing Cruises & Snorkeling Aruba
A pirate-ship sunset dinner sail. Previously listed from $117 for about 2 hours.
Check AvailabilityBoth boat types can provide enjoyable snorkeling excursions. The main differences are usually the atmosphere, itinerary and onboard activities rather than the vessel category itself.
Jolly Pirates combines snorkeling with the character of a pirate-style schooner. For some visitors, the rope swing and ship atmosphere are just as memorable as the snorkeling itself.
Neither boat type guarantees better marine-life sightings.
What matters more is where the operator stops, sea conditions, visibility and the time spent snorkeling. See Best Snorkeling Cruises in Aruba.
For sunset sailing, we generally prefer a catamaran if you're seeking a quiet or romantic experience.
However, Jolly Pirates may be more enjoyable if you prefer a social atmosphere.
| Sunset priority | Our recommendation |
|---|---|
| Romantic evening | Relaxed catamaran |
| Social group outing | Jolly Pirates |
| Lower-priced ticket | Compare both boat types |
| Dinner cruise | Compare specific dinner experiences |
| Private sunset charter | Catamaran charter |
| Pirate-themed experience | Jolly Pirates |
If you've narrowed your choice to these two operators, read Red Sail Sunset Sail vs Jolly Pirates Sunset Sail. That guide covers the two specific products, including prices, appetizers, departure points and cancellation considerations.
There isn't a universal winner.
A catamaran may be appealing to families who want a structured snorkeling excursion, a shorter sail or particular onboard amenities.
Some boats have water slides or other activities, while others focus on relaxation. Check the individual tour's minimum age and swimming requirements.
Jolly Pirates can be especially memorable for older children and teenagers who enjoy pirate-themed adventures.
However, active water activities may not be suitable for every child.
Younger children: Start by comparing family-friendly catamaran experiences.
Older children and teenagers: Consider Jolly Pirates' snorkeling excursions.
Families with non-swimmers: Check the exact tour's requirements and safety arrangements before booking.
For a romantic sunset, our preference is usually a catamaran with a relaxed atmosphere. Red Sail's appetizer cruise is one example.
However, some catamarans can also be lively, so don't assume every catamaran is quiet.
Jolly Pirates is a great alternative for couples who prefer a playful, social date night.
Honeymoon or anniversary: Relaxed catamaran sunset sail.
Adventurous daytime date: Jolly Pirates snorkeling trip.
Special private experience: Private catamaran charter. See Best Romantic Cruises in Aruba.
Private charters are another major reason to consider a catamaran.
Unlike a shared cruise, a private charter reserves the vessel for your group, subject to the operator's booking terms.
They can be appealing for:
The ArubaBuddies listings have included private catamaran experiences from Octopus and Delphi Watersports, with historical prices starting around $1,800.
These are typically whole-boat prices rather than per-person tickets. See Best Private Catamaran Charters in Aruba.
Not necessarily for every traveler.
Catamarans and schooners have different motion characteristics, but the actual experience depends on the vessel, sea state, wind and sailing conditions.
If you're sensitive to motion, consider:
Neither a catamaran nor a pirate ship can guarantee a motion-free trip.
Before choosing any Aruba sailing excursion, review the exact product details.
Sunset cruises commonly last around two hours, while snorkeling excursions may run longer.
Check whether the tour visits reefs, shipwrecks or other locations that interest you. Stops can change because of sea conditions.
An open bar doesn't necessarily mean food is included. Check whether the tour provides snacks, appetizers, lunch or dinner.
These are tour-specific amenities, not features guaranteed by the boat category.
Many excursions leave from the Palm Beach area, but meeting points vary.
Some bookings offer flexible cancellation while others have more restrictive conditions. Always check the current terms for your selected date.
Read recent reviews for the exact excursion rather than relying solely on the operator's overall reputation.
FAQ
Both can be excellent ways to experience Aruba's coastline.
Choose a catamaran if you want more choice, a relaxed sunset cruise, a snorkeling-and-lunch excursion or a private charter.
Choose Jolly Pirates if you want a distinctive pirate-ship experience, a social atmosphere and an adventurous daytime sail.
For couples planning a romantic sunset, we'd start with Red Sail or another relaxed catamaran operator.
For families with adventurous older children and groups of friends, we'd seriously consider Jolly Pirates.
And if snorkeling is your main priority, compare the actual itinerary before worrying about the boat style.
Catamaran Sunset Cruises
Compare sunset sails by price, food and atmosphere.
Catamaran Snorkeling Tours
Snorkel sails, including shorter and lunch options.
Jolly Pirates Cruises
Pirate-ship snorkeling, sunset sails and dinner cruises.
Private Catamaran Charters
Whole-boat options for celebrations and small groups.
Also see Red Sail Sports vs Jolly Pirates and Jolly Pirates vs Dolphin Catamaran.
Last reviewed: November 2026. Prices, tour schedules, activities, vessel amenities and booking terms can change. Confirm the current details before booking.
ArubaBuddies is an independent Aruba travel guide. We may earn a commission from bookings made through our links, at no additional cost to you.
A few nearby reads that pair with this page.

Compare Red Sail Sports and Jolly Pirates in Aruba. See sunset cruise prices, snorkeling tours, departure locations and which boat is best for you.

Red Sail or Jolly Pirates sunset cruise? Compare prices, drinks, food, cancellation policies, boat atmosphere and departure piers before booking.

Compare Jolly Pirates and Dolphin Catamaran snorkeling tours in Aruba. See prices, water slides, rope swings, family suitability and which to book.

Compare Aruba sunset cruises by price and style, including Red Sail, Dolphin, Octopus, Black Pearl, Pelican, Arusun, and dinner sails.

Compare romantic dinner cruises in Aruba, including Monforte III's onboard four-course dinner and Pelican's sunset sail with seaside dining.

Compare 3 affordable Aruba snorkeling cruises: Arusun, Banana Adventure and Dolphin Catamaran. See prices, shipwreck stops, activities and inclusions.
Explore Aruba Boat Cruises
Compare catamaran sails and pirate-ship cruises.
Compare Aruba Boat Cruises